BMN Boston

Get our mobile app!

Download on the App Store

Edgartown vs West Tisbury, MA — June 2026

A side-by-side comparison of Edgartown and West Tisbury, Massachusetts — home prices, property taxes, schools, and market conditions.

Updated June 2026 · Live MLS data
More Affordable
West Tisbury
Lower Property Tax
Edgartown
Faster Market
West Tisbury

Edgartown vs West Tisbury: How They Compare

MetricEdgartownWest Tisbury
Median List Price$4M$1.8M
Price / Sq Ft$1,602$1,008
Active Listings428
Avg. Days on Market143121
Market TypeColdCold
Property Tax ($/$1k)$2.65$4.53

Comparing Edgartown and West Tisbury, Massachusetts: Edgartown has a median list price of $4M, while West Tisbury is around $1.8M. West Tisbury is the more affordable of the two.

On property taxes, Edgartown charges $2.65 per $1,000 versus West Tisbury at $4.53, so Edgartown has the lower rate. Edgartown is currently a cold market and West Tisbury a cold market.

Both figures come from live MLS data. Browse current listings in Edgartown or West Tisbury to compare homes side by side.

Browse homes for sale in Edgartown → See every active listing with photos, pricing, and full details.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Edgartown or West Tisbury more affordable?

West Tisbury is more affordable, with a median list price of $1.8M versus $4M in Edgartown.

Which has lower property taxes, Edgartown or West Tisbury?

Edgartown has the lower residential property tax rate: $2.65 per $1,000 versus $4.53 in West Tisbury.

Market figures are derived from live MLS data and are provided for informational purposes only. They are not an appraisal or a guarantee of value. Last updated June 2026.