Plum Island Real Estate

7 homes for sale • Median price: $3,371

7 properties found in Plum Island

Sort by:

Plum Island Market Overview

Real-time market statistics for rentals in Plum Island Data as of Dec 6, 2025 at 2:28 AM

The Plum Island rental market currently offers 7 apartments and homes for rent with a median rent of $3,371/month. With a market heat index of 50, this is a balanced rental market. Rentals typically get leased with more time for renters to decide, averaging 80 days on market. Monthly rents range from $2,500 to $4,895, accommodating various budgets and lifestyle needs.

Active Rentals

$3,371 /mo

Average Price

80 days

Avg. Days on Market

$3K - $5K

Price Range

Property Types in Plum Island

Single Family Residence 5

Apartment 1

Condominium 1

Price Reduced

$4,895 /mo $5,500

3 bd 2.0 ba 2,115 sqft

4 Northern Blvd Newbury, MA 01951

Single Family Residence Built 1996

$2,500 /mo

2 bd 1.0 ba 1,000 sqft

68 Southern Blvd #WINTER Newbury, MA 01951

Single Family Residence

Price Reduced

$2,900 /mo $3,500

2 bd 2.0 ba 1,254 sqft

8 58th St #1 Newburyport, MA 01950

Single Family Residence Built 2003

Price Reduced

$3,350 /mo $3,600

4 bd 2.0 ba 1,660 sqft

99 North Reservation Terr #WINTER Newburyport, MA 01950

Condominium Built 1985

This Week

$3,700 /mo

3 bd 1.0 ba 1,768 sqft

6 46th Street #1 Newbury, MA 01951

Single Family Residence

Price Reduced

$3,100 /mo $4,000

3 bd 3.0 ba 1,750 sqft

65 Plum Island Turnpike Newbury, MA 01951

Single Family Residence Built 2017

This Week

$3,150 /mo

3 bd 1.0 ba 1,123 sqft

49 Northern Blvd #A Newbury, MA 01951

Apartment

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about Plum Island real estate

How many apartments are for rent in Plum Island?

There are currently 7 apartments and homes for rent in Plum Island, MA. Our listings are updated daily with the latest available rentals.

What is the average rent in Plum Island?

The median monthly rent in Plum Island is $3,371. Rental prices vary based on unit size, amenities, and specific location within the area.

How quickly do rentals get leased in Plum Island?

Rentals in Plum Island typically get leased within 80 days on average. Popular units may rent faster, so scheduling a viewing promptly is recommended.

Is Plum Island a good place to rent?

Plum Island offers a variety of rental options in MA including apartments, condos, and houses. Contact our team for help finding a rental that fits your needs and budget.

Ready to Find Your Home in Plum Island?

Get expert guidance on buying or selling in Plum Island. Schedule a consultation to discuss your real estate goals.

Schedule Consultation Call (617) 955-2224

Steven Novak Real Estate Agent