57 Butlers Cove Rd, Edgartown MA 02539
Edgartown, MA 02539 • Edgartown
$18,500,000
Est. $115,047/month
Track this home for price, status, and open-house alerts.
About this home
Set within the exclusive 200 acre coastal enclave of Herring Creek Farm, just minutes from Edgartown Village, Sunset Farm is a sprawling 12-acre waterfront property with an unprecedented 3 contiguous parcels. The three large building envelopes provide a rare opportunity to create multiple, substantial residences and amenities tailored to your vision. Sunset Farm has 700 feet of shoreline on the pristine 900-acre Edgartown Great Pond, a walking path to a private beach on the Atlantic Ocean, and is surrounded by the bucolic beauty of Herring Creek Farm. This unique assemblage affords the development of an expansive private family compound in one of Martha’s Vineyard's most coveted waterfront locations.
View in the App
Save this property, schedule tours instantly, and get alerts when the price drops
Scan with phone
Public Records & Permits
Log in to view assessor & tax records, ownership history, and recent building permits for this property.
BMN Estimate
Get the number an algorithm can't give you
A free agent CMA factors in condition, upgrades, and the street — the things comps alone can't see.
Recently Sold Nearby
Property History
Market Insights
Property Timeline
Pending Sale
Aug 6, 2026
Offer accepted, sale pending
Listed for Sale
Jun 16, 2026
$18,500,000
Original listing
Agent: Maggie Gold Seelig
Office: MGS Group Real Estate LTD
| Date | Event | Price | Change | $/sqft | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 08/06/2026 | ⏳ Pending Sale | - | - | - | Offer accepted, sale pending |
| 06/16/2026 | 🏠 Listed for Sale | $18,500,000 | - | - | Original listing |
Tax History
| Year | Taxes | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $39,614 | $15,973,643 |
Financial Details
Annual Property Tax
$39,614
Tax Year 2026
HOA Fee
$18,000
Per month
Assessed Value
$15,973,643
Facts & Features
Home Facts
Type
Land
Style
Residential
Lot Size
12.77 acres
Exterior
Construction
None
Architecture
None
Roof
None
Features
None
Pool
None
Spa
None
Fencing
None
Patio/Porch
None
Utilities
Electric
Underground
Water
Private, Other
Sewer
Private Sewer, Other
Gas
Other (see Remarks)
Other
None
Financial
Annual Tax
$39,614
Assessed Value
$15,973,643
MA Disclosures
Seller Disclosures
Offering Includes 3 Parcels: 57 Butlers Cove Road (44-44), 15 Forever Wild Way (44-45.12) And 16 Forever Wild Way (44-45.11). There Are Structures And Dwellings Currently On Property. Some Images Are Conceptual Designs Or Virtually Rendered.
Additional Details
Possession
None
Accepted Financing
None
Structure Type
[]
Documents
None
County
Dukes
Total market time (incl. prior listings)
51 days
Property Overview
Property Type
Residential
Listing Type
Sale Pending
Floor Layout
Interactive room guide
Floor Layout
Display Options
Room Markers
BABathroom (4)
BRBedroom (5)
DDining (1)
KKitchen (1)
LLiving (2)
OOffice (1)
Conceptual diagram based on MLS room data. It is not to scale and is not a substitute for architectural plans or on-site measurements.
Interior Features
Flooring:
Appliances:
Interior Features:
Windows:
Basement:
Laundry:
Security:
Construction & Materials
Structure Type:
Exterior Materials:
Roof:
Foundation:
Heating, Cooling & Utilities
Heating:
Cooling:
Hot Water:
Water Source:
Private, Other
Sewer:
Private Sewer, Other
Energy Features:
Exterior & Lot
Exterior Features:
Patio & Porch:
Fencing:
Other Structures:
Lot Features:
Easements, Level, Additional Land Available
Road Surface:
Parking & Garage
Parking Features:
Special Features
Waterfront:
Yes
Waterfront Type:
Waterfront, 0 to 1/10 Mile To Beach, Beach Ownership(Private)
View:
Yes
View Type:
Scenic View(s)
Community Amenities:
Shopping, Tennis Court(s), Stable(s), Golf, Bike Path, Conservation Area, Marina
Nearby Schools
School information not available for this location.
Monthly Payment Calculator
Monthly Payment
$0
Principal, interest, taxes & insurance
Loan Amount
$0
After down payment
Total Interest
$0
Over life of loan
Total Cost
$0
Including down payment
%
Down: $0
%
Monthly Payment Breakdown
Principal & Interest
$0
Property Tax
$3,301
Homeowners Insurance
$200
HOA Fee
$18,000/mo
PMI (if <20% down)
$0
Loan Summary
Total of 360 payments
$0
Total principal paid
$0
Total interest paid
$0
Rate Impact
-0.5% Rate
$0/mo
Save $0/mo
Current Rate
$0/mo
+0.5% Rate
$0/mo
Cost $0/mo
Payment Over Time
Year 1
95% Interest
Year 15
50/50
Year 30
95% Principal
* Estimates only. Actual payments may vary. Consult with a lender for accurate figures.
Location
Loading map...
Neighborhood
Edgartown
57 Butlers Cove Rd, Edgartown MA 02539
Edgartown, MA 02539
Listing Information
Listing Agent
Maggie Gold Seelig
Listing Office
MGS Group Real Estate LTD
Office Phone
617-714-4544
Agent MLS ID
CT003644
Office MLS ID
AN0499
Listing Data Updated
Aug 6, 2026 11:26 AM EDT
Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Data provided by MLS Property Information Network, Inc. All information should be independently verified.
Contact Us
Ask about this property — free, no obligation.
Similar Homes for Sale
Comparable Properties
Customize Comparable Search
Finding comparable properties...
Loading market insights for Edgartown.