BMN Boston

Get our mobile app!

Download on the App Store

428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635

Barnstable, MA 02635 • Cotuit
$625,000
4
Beds
1
Baths
720
Sq Ft
$868
Price/Sq Ft
0.43
Acres
1900
Year Built
5
Parking
-1
Days on Market
Closed Listed Jan 5, 2026 • MLS# 73465256 Copied! • Updated Jan 6, 2026

Sale Statistics

Sale Overview
Original List Price: $799,000
Final Sale Price: $625,000
Difference: $174,000 (-21.8%)
Performance Metrics
78.2%
List to Sale Ratio
Sold below asking price
-1
Days on Market
Very fast sale
Price per Square Foot Analysis
Original $/sq ft: $1,110
Sale $/sq ft: $868
This property sold for $868 per square foot
Sale Summary

This property sold for 21.8% below the original asking price.

With only -1 days on market, this was a quick sale compared to typical market conditions.

Nearby Sales Comparison

Based on 2 similar properties sold within 0.5 miles in the last 90 days

This Property
$868/sq ft
Area Average
$524/sq ft
Difference
+65.7%

This property sold for significantly more per square foot than similar nearby properties, suggesting premium features or condition.

About this home

Quintessential Cotuit home on beautiful parcel on Main Street. Enjoy the village and all it offers, just a short distance to beaches, local market, library and Cotuit Kettleer's Lowell Park. The property has had major renovations to restore the original charm to this home. New kitchen with granite counters and stainless-steel appliances, new bathroom with granite counter and tile around tub/shower, newer roof, newer windows, new electrical and plumbing, newer hot water heater and furnace, new heat pump with AC in first floor master, and beautiful wrap around screened porch for summer dining or just sitting and relaxing. Title V report in hand. This property needs nothing and has expansion possibilities. Rare opportunity in Cotuit!

View in the App

Save this property, schedule tours instantly, and get alerts when the price drops

Scan to download BMN Boston app Scan with phone
Get the full experience in the BMN Boston app

BMN Estimate

Get the number an algorithm can't give you

A free agent CMA factors in condition, upgrades, and the street — the things comps alone can't see.

Recently Sold Nearby

Property History

Market Insights

99.7%
Price Range

Property Timeline

Current Active Listing - MLS #73507775
Full transaction history available when tracking began
🏡
Currently Listed
Apr 27, 2026
$2,700
MLS #73507775 - Active
Sold
Jan 6, 2026
Property sold
🏠
Listed for Sale
Jan 5, 2026
$799,000
Original listing
Agent: Joseph W. Sullivan Office: Coldwell Banker Realty - Boston
🏠
Listed for Sale
Jan 5, 2026
$799,000
Original listing
Office: Coldwell Banker Realty - Boston

Tax History

Year Taxes Assessment
2025 $3,692 $442,200

Financial Details

Annual Property Tax
$3,692
Tax Year 2025
Assessed Value
$442,200

Facts & Features

Central AC

Home Facts

Type Residential
Style Single Family Residence
Year Built 1900
Living Area 720 sq ft
Lot Size 0.43 acres
Bedrooms 4
Full Baths 1
Total Rooms 6

Interior

Heating Forced Air, Natural Gas
Cooling Central Air, Evaporative Cooling
Flooring Wood
Appliances Gas Water Heater, Range, Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Washer, Dryer
Fireplace None
Basement Bulkhead
Laundry None
Features None

Exterior

Construction Frame
Architecture Cape
Roof Shingle
Features Porch - Screened, Storage, Professional Landscaping, Decorative Lighting, Screens, Outdoor Shower
Pool None
Spa None
Fencing None
Patio/Porch Screened
Features Off Street, Stone/gravel
Total Spaces 5
Electric None
Water Public
Sewer Public Sewer
Gas None
Other For Gas Range
Annual Tax $3,692
Assessed Value $442,200
Fee Includes None
Amenities None
Optional Fee Includes None
Seller Disclosures None
Possession None
Accepted Financing None
Structure Type []
Sq Ft Source Public Record
Documents None
County Barnstable
Total market time (incl. prior listings) 94 days

Property Overview

Property Type
Single Family Residence
Listing Type
For Sale
Year Built
1900
Bedrooms
4
Full Bathrooms
1
Living Area
720 sq ft
Total Rooms
6

Room Details

Other Floor

Bathroom1
Bedroom5
Bedroom4
Bedroom3
Dining Room
Kitchen
Bathroom2
Bedroom2
Living Room
Bathroom3
Master Bedroom
Office
Family Room
Master Bathroom
No

Interior Features

Flooring: Wood
Appliances: Gas Water Heater, Range, Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Washer, Dryer
Interior Features:
Windows: Screens
Basement: Bulkhead
Laundry:
Security:

Construction & Materials

Style: Cape
Year Built: 1900
Structure Type:
Exterior Materials: Frame
Roof: Shingle
Foundation: Stone

Heating, Cooling & Utilities

Heating: Forced Air, Natural Gas
Cooling: Central Air, Evaporative Cooling
Hot Water:
Water Source: Public
Sewer: Public Sewer
Energy Features:

Exterior & Lot

Exterior Features: Porch - Screened, Storage, Professional Landscaping, Decorative Lighting, Screens, Outdoor Shower
Patio & Porch: Screened
Fencing:
Other Structures:
Lot Features: Cleared, Level
Road Surface:

Parking & Garage

Total Parking Spaces: 5
Parking Features: Off Street, Stone/Gravel
School District
Barnstable School District local
B
School Safety 2024-25
2.9% Above Average
2.1% Suspensions 2.2% In-School 0.8% Emergency
2.6% below state avg
E

Elementary Schools

10 schools
Cape Cod Academy
2.8 mi
Strong Athletics
Grades K-12
St. John Paul II School
8.2 mi
Grades 05-12
Trinity Christian Academy of Cape Cod
9.1 mi
Grades PK-12
B-
Barnstable United Elementary School
3.7 mi | #458 of 824 | Score: 45.8
Improved 150 spots from last year
-12.4 below state avg
714 students Diverse
Rising School Diverse Student Body
Grades 04-05
A
West Villages Elementary School
3.7 mi | #144 of 824 | Score: 57.3
Improved 187 spots from last year
-0.9 below state avg
416 students Diverse
Rising School
Grades K-03
Fair Acres Country Day School
3.7 mi
Grades PK-K
B
Centerville Elementary School
4.7 mi | #394 of 824 | Score: 48.0
Dropped 159 spots from last year
-10.2 below state avg
267 students Diverse
Grades K-03
Enoch Cobb Early Learning Center
6.6 mi
150 students Diverse
Diverse Student Body
Grades PK
C-
Hyannis West Elementary School
6.6 mi | #668 of 824 | Score: 37.5
Dropped 2 spots from last year
-20.7 below state avg
309 students Diverse
Diverse Student Body
Grades K-03
C+
West Barnstable Elementary School
7.7 mi | #502 of 824 | Score: 44.6
Improved 168 spots from last year
-13.6 below state avg
237 students Diverse
Rising School
Grades K-03
M

Middle Schools

2 schools
Bayberry Christian School
3.4 mi
Grades 01-08
C
Barnstable Intermediate School
6.6 mi | #270 of 352 | Score: 34.4
Improved 18 spots from last year
-23.8 below state avg
642 students Diverse
Diverse Student Body
Grades 05-07
H

High Schools

3 schools
C+
Barnstable High School
6.6 mi | #228 of 346 | Score: 48.6
Improved 39 spots from last year
-9.6 below state avg
1,652 students Diverse
18 sports • 1,820 athletes
Rising School Career Tech Programs College Ready Curriculum Strong Athletics
Grades 08-12
Living Independently Forever, Inc.
7.3 mi
Grades 09-12
A
Sturgis Charter Public School
8.3 mi | #38 of 346 | Score: 68.5
Improved 38 spots from last year
+10.3 above state avg
825 students Moderate
High Graduation Rate Rising School College Ready Curriculum
Grades 09-12
Learn about these ratings

Location

Loading map...

Neighborhood

Cotuit

428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635

Barnstable, MA 02635

Listing Information

Listing Office Coldwell Banker Realty - Boston
Office Phone 617-266-4430
Agent MLS ID BB803407
Office MLS ID AN6192
Listing Data Updated Jan 6, 2026 9:51 AM EST
Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Data provided by MLS Property Information Network, Inc. All information should be independently verified.

Contact Us

Steven Novak
Steven Novak
BMN Boston Real Estate
Ask about this property — free, no obligation.

Similar Homes for Sale

Comparable Properties

Customize Comparable Search

Finding comparable properties...

Market Analytics for Barnstable, MA

Real-time market trends and pricing data for this area

428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 1 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 2 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 3 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 4 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 5 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 6 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 7 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 8 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 9 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 10 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 11 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 12 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 13 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 14 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 15 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 16 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 17 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 18 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 19 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 20 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 21 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 22 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 23 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 24 428 Main Street, Barnstable MA 02635 - Photo 25
Steven Novak

Steven Novak

BMN Boston Real Estate

Your message will be sent to Steven Novak.

Schedule a Tour