Tisbury Real Estate

19 homes for sale • Median price: $2,637,158

19 properties found in Tisbury

Sort by:

Tisbury Market Overview

Real-time market statistics for homes for sale in Tisbury Data as of May 15, 2026 at 5:13 PM

The Tisbury real estate market currently offers 19 homes for sale with a median listing price of $2.6M. With a market heat index of 15, this is a buyer-friendly market. Properties typically sell with more time for buyer consideration, averaging 97 days on market. Prices range from $525K to $9.3M, offering options for various budgets.

19

Active Listings

$2,637,158

Average Price

97 days

Avg. Days on Market

$525K - $9.3M

Price Range

2,377 sqft

Avg. Living Area

$1,185 /sqft

Avg. Price/Sqft

Property Types in Tisbury

Single Family Residence 15

Condominium 3

Residential 1

22 Oklahoma Ave

$1,300,000 $1,445,000

4 bd 2.5 ba 1,738 sqft

22 Oklahoma Ave Tisbury, MA 02568

Single Family Residence Built 1960

5 Pinetree Lane

4 bd 3.0 ba 2,730 sqft

5 Pinetree Lane Tisbury, MA 02568

Single Family Residence Built 1927

187 Lagoon Pond Road

$2,695,000 $2,825,000

5 bd 2.0 ba 2,386 sqft

187 Lagoon Pond Road Tisbury, MA 02575

Single Family Residence Built 1850

124 Skiff Avenue #A-11

2 bd 1.0 ba 725 sqft

124 Skiff Avenue #A-11 Tisbury, MA 02568

Condominium Built 1953

159 Lake Street

5 bd 4.0 ba 3,328 sqft

159 Lake Street Tisbury, MA 02568

Single Family Residence Built 1999

33 Goethals Way

$9,250,000 $10,500,000

5 bd 2.5 ba 2,794 sqft

33 Goethals Way Tisbury, MA 02568

Single Family Residence Built 1900

Lot 1 Dolan Avenue

Lot 1 Dolan Avenue Tisbury, MA 02568

17 Mariner Rd

3 bd 2.0 ba 1,152 sqft

17 Mariner Rd Tisbury, MA 02568

Single Family Residence Built 1983

33 Lagoon Pond Road

$1,975,000 $2,150,000

3 bd 3.0 ba 1,680 sqft

33 Lagoon Pond Road Tisbury, MA 02568

Single Family Residence Built 2025

261 Sandpiper Lane #12

3 bd 3.0 ba 1,682 sqft

261 Sandpiper Lane #12 Tisbury, MA 02539

Condominium Built 1998

26 Union Court #7

2 bd 3.0 ba 1,532 sqft

26 Union Court #7 Tisbury, MA 02568

Condominium Built 2023

94 Weaver Lane

4 bd 3.0 ba 2,715 sqft

94 Weaver Lane Tisbury, MA 02568

Single Family Residence Built 1970

Nearby Cities

Explore homes in communities near Tisbury

Falmouth

93 listings 10.2 mi

Mashpee

93 listings 11.5 mi

Edgartown

37 listings 6.5 mi

Oak Bluffs

18 listings 1.8 mi

West Tisbury

10 listings 4.8 mi

Chilmark

9 listings 8.8 mi

Aquinnah

3 listings 13.9 mi

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about Tisbury real estate

How many homes are for sale in Tisbury?

There are currently 19 homes for sale in Tisbury, MA. Our listings are updated daily with the latest properties from the MLS.

What is the median home price in Tisbury?

The median listing price for homes in Tisbury is $2,637,158. Home prices can vary based on size, condition, and specific location within the area.

How long do homes stay on the market in Tisbury?

Homes in Tisbury typically sell within 97 days on average. Market conditions can affect how quickly homes sell.

Is Tisbury a good place to buy a home?

Tisbury offers a variety of housing options in MA. Contact our team for personalized recommendations based on your needs and budget.

Ready to Find Your Home in Tisbury?

Get expert guidance on buying or selling in Tisbury. Schedule a consultation to discuss your real estate goals.

Schedule Consultation Call (617) 955-2224

Steven Novak

Steven Novak Real Estate Agent